LANDOVER, Md. – The game was tied 3-3 at halftime, and by the six-minute mark of the fourth quarter, it was just 13-9.
To put it into perspective, imagine a lot of people still somewhat sober around midnight or 1 a.m. But it’s that final hour – in this case, the last five minutes – that can flip the most ordinary situation upside down.
Make no mistake, this Cowboys-Commanders game was pure chaos.
Five touchdowns in the final five minutes? Are you serious? Two kickoff returns for touchdowns, including KaVontae Turpin’s remarkable fumble recovery, where he slowly jogged to the middle, then exploded with speed, spun, and dashed into the end zone for a touchdown that may go down as one of the greatest special teams plays in Cowboys history.
And to think, the drama wasn’t even over yet.
The first 55 minutes had all the feel of a classic NFC East showdown, with more mistakes than big plays. But the final five minutes? It was like a Wimbledon match, with back-and-forth action that left everyone in the stadium with sore necks.
Let me say this before we get too deep into the game: I’m often asked, especially on my daily Cowboys podcast Cowboys StoryLine, what my favorite game of all time is. I always bring up my first game covering the team in 1999, when the Cowboys came back from 21 down in the fourth quarter to beat Washington in Week 1. It had Emmitt Smith, Michael Irvin, Troy Aikman, and Rocket Ismail making huge plays. That game will never be topped, simply because it was my first one.
But right now, as I’m still trying to catch my breath, I’m going to say this latest game against Washington is a very close No. 2.
Who knows, 25 years from now, we probably won’t remember names like Cooper Rush, Turpin, Josh Butler, Luke Schoonmaker, or Chauncey Golston in the same way we do the Cowboys legends of the past. But I can promise you, we won’t see another game with this many back-and-forth plays in the final five minutes anytime soon.
Interestingly, the first comment I saw on Twitter was about how lucky the Cowboys were that Washington missed that extra point.
Here’s my response: The Cowboys have been called many things in recent weeks, but “lucky” certainly hasn’t been one of them.
Yes, Commanders kicker Austin Seibert missed a crucial kick to tie the game. But let’s not forget, he also missed another important kick earlier in the third quarter. Kickers can’t afford to let those mistakes creep into their heads – it’s hard to block that out.
Now, let’s flip the script and give some credit to Brandon Aubrey. His first two kicks on the day were a disaster – one blocked and the other hitting the upright. How did he respond? He drilled a 46-yard field goal before halftime that gave the Cowboys momentum, and then hit a 48-yard field goal in the fourth quarter, along with all his extra points, which we know were crucial.
If the Cowboys were fortunate that Washington missed their kick, let’s give them credit for nailing their own.
When you think about the full 60 minutes, the Cowboys were the better team. Are they the better team overall? The record might suggest otherwise, but if you watched this game closely, from offense to defense to special teams, the Cowboys outperformed Washington. Rush will never be as flashy as a guy like Jayden Daniels, who’s already a star in this league, but Rush was more efficient on Sunday, taking care of the ball and managing the game better.
Let’s not forget the players who weren’t available for the Cowboys. This was supposed to be the game where they got back key players like Jordan Lewis, Marshawn Kneeland, and DaRon Bland. Yet, they had to play without both starting guards, Zack Martin and Tyler Smith, cornerback Trevon Diggs, and tight end Jake Ferguson. In total, 13 Pro Bowl-caliber players were inactive.
Think about it – some of the key contributors in this game were backups for those injured players. Josh Butler stepped up with 12 tackles, a sack, and three pass breakups filling in for Diggs. T.J. Bass and Brock Hoffman brought toughness to the offensive line, helping the Cowboys run the ball effectively. And Schoonmaker had two crucial catches, including the 22-yard touchdown that should’ve sealed the game.
Of course, Rush is the next man up for Dak Prescott and had his best performance of the season. He wasn’t flashy, but he was solid and effective – exactly what the team needed.
Now, you can win with a backup quarterback if your defense plays lights out. It’s tough to swallow that they gave up the 86-yard touchdown in the final seconds, which spoiled what had been a stellar defensive effort. But overall, Mike Zimmer’s defense deserves a lot of credit for keeping Washington off the board for most of the game. It wasn’t perfect, but there’s plenty to build on, especially if they can get some injured players back.
As I’m typing this, I keep looking at the stat sheet, trying to convince myself that game actually happened.
But it most certainly did. This season has been full of surprises, week after week. And while most of them have worked against the Cowboys, this one was an unforgettable win.